Man, talk about stereotyping ~ even our dolls have to flee their "dangerous" city communities to pursue the American Dream in the 'burbs! Check out the new Mexican "American Girl" doll (story below). I agree with Alejandra L. Ibanez, quoted in the story ~ leaving our communities (ai, and for the suburbs no less) should not be the watermark for improving our lives ~ improving the communities we already live in...that should be the mark.(!) Below the story, you should check out the thoughtful comment posted by my good friend Ginger ~ who is my eyes, ears, and brilliant mind in Chicago, where she has lived for many years as a single woman, a kick-ass mom, and now a kick-ass attorney. Now, on to the story, from YahooNews:
CHICAGO - Some residents of Chicago's largely Hispanic Pilsen section are upset over a new doll in the popular American Girl series because her storyline says the Mexican-American youngster and her family left the "dangerous" neighborhood for a better life in the suburbs.
Many in the West Side neighborhood say the characterization is insulting and inaccurate.
"It's very offensive and it's really a slap in the face to the hardworking people of the Pilsen community," said Alvaro R. Obregon, who lives near where the doll, Marisol,
supposedly lived before setting out for suburban Des Plaines.
According to the biography that accompanies the doll, which was introduced just after Christmas, she is the daughter of a transit worker and an accountant. One day her mother tells Marisol the family is leaving their apartment for a house in the suburbs.
The old neighborhood "was no place for me to grow up," the doll's story says. "It was dangerous, and there was no place for me to play."
American Girl officials said that they never intended to insult the community.
"Our feeling is that when people read the book in its entirety, I think they'll see the picture that we painted of Marisol in the book is from a very warm, lively and very close-knit
community," American Girl spokeswoman Stephanie Spanos said Wednesday.
Spanos added that the "dangerous" comment was a reference to traffic in the big city and that Marisol's parents moved to Des Plaines because they wanted a house and a yard for their daughter to play in. {Sidebar: The fact that American Girl believes its own explanation only serves to highlight the fact that general statements and assumptions like theirs are based on inherent prejudices and stereotyping ~ people of color primarily comprise our city communities, it is a fact that suburbs are primarily white; and so to make blanket statements about a Mexican girl leaving "her dangerous neighborhood" for the safety and opportunity of the suburbs, without taking into consideration the inherently offensive nature of the statement, not to mention the effect, well...poor marketing is the least of American Girl's problems.}
Police spokesman Pat Camden said Pilsen's crime level is pretty typical for Chicago. "Crime there is not the highest and it's not the lowest," he said.
Although crime was down 6 percent last year in Pilsen, the neighborhood still grapples with gang violence and high dropout rates.
"It's a community that doesn't give up and doesn't run from its problems," said Obregon, who works with the community group The Resurrection Project. "It's a community of faith, of hardworking people, and that's why when this comes out I'm sort of taken aback."
Pilsen has long been a port of entry for immigrants in Chicago. From the early 1900s until about 30 years ago, mostly Eastern Europeans lived in the area. Now it is one of the biggest Mexican communities in the United States. In the summer it is known for its outdoor Catholic Mass and festivals that fill the streets with the smell of tamales and the sound of mariachi bands.
American Girl dolls were introduced in 1986. The dolls, which have become a must-have for many girls, also feature other ethnic characters, including a Hispanic girl living in
colonial New Mexico, a black girl during the Civil War and an American Indian girl.
Alejandra L. Ibanez, executive director of the community group Pilsen Alliance, said American Girl missed an opportunity.
"I wish that they would not have had Marisol leave her community so that little girls like Marisol living in the inner city can be proud of their neighborhood and not have the perception that they must leave the neighborhood so that they can do better for themselves," Ibanez said.
___
On the Net: http://www.americangirl.com
Recent Comments